Alfano's Pizza Restaurant Carthage
Alfano's Pizza Restaurant Logo

Alfano's Pizza Restaurant

@

4.6866 reviews

Alfano's Pizza Restaurant offers a cozy ambiance and a delightful array of Italian dishes. Nestled in the heart of Carthage, this spot welcomes everyone. Whether it's a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner, they cater to all with local specialties and a friendly atmosphere.

From the moment you step inside, a warm vibe surrounds you. The historic brick building adds to the charm. Alfano's is more than just a pizzeria; it’s a gathering place for families, friends, and anyone looking for great food. With a variety of wines to choose from, it heightens the dining experience.

Prices remain affordable, making it easy to indulge without spending much. A visit here feels like a little escape to Italy, even if just for a meal. Every detail, from the cozy seating to the walls adorned with local art, ensures a welcome feel. Each dish served is made from quality ingredients, promising satisfaction.

About

Located at 93 S Adams St, Alfano's Pizza boasts a rich history in Carthage. The restaurant stands proudly in the town square, a testament to community and culinary tradition. Longtime locals and visitors alike have embraced this gem, creating a cozy, familiar atmosphere.

The team focuses on traditional Italian recipes. Each day, the kitchen buzzes with activity as chefs prepare fresh dishes. Many recipes are family secrets handed down. The restaurant’s history is woven into the fabric of the town, connecting generations through food.

Alfano's is known for its heartfelt service. Many staff members have been part of the experience for years. Their dedication shines through in how they treat every guest. This combination of quality food and community spirit creates a welcoming dining experience.

Get in Touch

93 S Adams St, Carthage, IL 62321, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday Closed
  • Tuesday Closed
  • Wednesday 11:00-14:00 16:00-21:00
  • Thursday 11:00-14:00 16:00-21:00
  • Friday 11:00-14:00 16:00-21:00
  • Saturday 11:00-14:00 16:00-21:00
  • Sunday 11:00-14:00 16:00-20:00

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"Service and Atmosphere were very good. Pizza was hot to order- and took about 15 minutes to get to table, though I wish they would have cooked it a little longer to develop a better undercarriage."

- Ben M.

"We stopped here on our way through town. The food was amazing and the prices were better! We got a little bit of random things to try. Chicago style pizza, ravioli and subs. Our total was under $40. We will definitely stop back in the next time we come by!"

- Katrina F.

"1st time eating there. The place was very busy. The food was great, I had the large Philly cheese steak, and my wife had the Chicken Alfredo. The main thing I saw people eating was the pizzas. That's definitely what I want to try next."

- Jack S.

"We felt like Italian, so we found this little gem nestled in Carthage's town square, so we thought we'd try it out. Historic brick bldg, comfortable vibes, everyone was so friendly and smiley. We ordered an XL Canadian Bacon, Bacon Pizza, Garlic Cheesy Bread, and a side salad. We wanted to take some home as well, which we had plenty of leftovers for later. We were there around 1pm, lunch rush maybe. Plenty of seating. Outdoor seating available too. The food was delivered in a timely manner. Hot, fresh, delicious! The husband loved the Sweet Tea too. Even when groups started piling in, we were never left alone to long by our server/waitress. The restrooms were clean and fully stocked! Cute photo op corners. It was my first time at a Alfano's within our area. Not sure if all of them are privately owned or not. Thank you for such a wonderful first experience! Hit all my marks for a 5 Review!"

- Maureen V.

"Wonderful Italian restaurant on the historic Carthage square. I've been there several times over the years and they have never disappointed. Always kind staff and quick service to boot. I had their very delicious Italian sub. In the past I have enjoyed their thin delicious crust Pizza. They get a thumbs up for me. Update. In addition I just enjoy their taco pizza. Lots of fresh toppings, crisp lettuce, and crunchy chips. Overall this is an excellent taco pizza!"

- Dan M.

"We went on a Friday evening on our way thru town. It was clean and the waitress was friendly, fast and efficient. Will go again."

- Tracie H.

"Really great prices and service, and everything was delicious! They have a really nice gluten free menu - highly recommend!"

- Addyson D.
Write a Review

Why Visit

Visiting Alfano's Pizza is a must for any food lover. Tantalizing Chicago-style pizzas and delicious pastas dominate the menu. Hot, fresh, and made to order, every dish delights taste buds. Local favorites include the ravioli and homemade lasagna, each bursting with flavor.

For a unique experience, try their taco pizza, packed with fresh toppings. Each bite offers a combination of flavors that is hard to resist. The restaurant also serves a variety of beers and wines, perfect for pairing with any meal. Enjoy a casual dining atmosphere that feels relaxed yet vibrant.

Tip: Weekdays offer a chance to dine without the weekend rush. Enjoy a quiet lunch or a pre-dinner snack. Alfano's welcomes solo diners and families alike. The spacious outdoor seating is also a highlight during warmer months. It allows for lovely meals under the sun.

Most Liked Things

Patrons rave about the pizza quality. The thin crust and generous toppings make it a standout. Many appreciate the quick service, ensuring meals are served hot and fresh. The cozy, friendly environment is perfect for gatherings or a solo visit.

The wine selection adds a touch of elegance to the experience. Guests enjoy unwinding with a glass after a long day. Also, the accessibility features make it easy for everyone to enjoy a meal, ensuring that everyone feels welcome.

Most Disliked Things

Some guests wish for more consistent cooking times on pizzas, as not every pie comes out perfectly. Others mention that during busy hours, service can lag slightly. A few have suggested expanding the menu further for more variety.

Occasionally, noise levels can rise during peak times. It might lead to a less intimate dining experience. However, the staff always tries their best to accommodate.

FAQ

What are the must-try dishes at Alfano's Pizza Restaurant?

Popular choices include the Genuine Italian Style Pizza and specialty pizzas like Bacon Cheeseburger or BBQ Chicken. Don't forget the Cannoli for dessert!

Is Alfano's suitable for families?

Yes, Alfano's offers a kids menu with options like personal pizza and chicken strips. High chairs are available for younger guests.

What are the restaurant's hours?

Alfano's generally opens for lunch and dinner. It's best to check their specific hours by calling the restaurant.

Does Alfano's offer takeout?

Yes, Alfano's provides takeout services for those who prefer to enjoy their meals at home. Just call ahead to place an order!

Is parking available at Alfano's?

Yes, there is free parking available, including accessible spots. Both on-site and street parking options are convenient.